ellie
4.1
That narrow vibrato in the chorus is a gift I rarely see, and your transition into the belt is truly flawless. However, I am still struggling to find the human being behind these neon clichés. You have the technical machinery of a superstar, but to win, you must find a song that is just as brave as your actual vocal ability tonight.
rhee
3.5
Your high tenor belt is a world class tool. But 'Neon Heartbeat' relies on tropes that felt dated years ago. I cannot sign a voice that simply refuses to find its own unique language today.
mochi
3.0
Your voice is a massive, tectonic event, but you are still trying to live inside a dollhouse of neon clichés. I am haunted by the ghost of a better song that lived inside your "out of control" delivery. You are a giant who is afraid of breaking the furniture. If you advance, you must decide to finally stop being so polite.